Should you block disposable email addresses?
If your product gives away something valuable at signup, such as free credits, trials, referral rewards or coupons, blocking disposable addresses is usually worth it, because they make claiming that value again and again nearly free. If signup gives nothing away, you may prefer to allow them and simply not count them as real users. The right answer depends on what a new account can take.
When should you block disposable emails?
Block them when one person creating many accounts costs you money or skews results: credit-based products, free trials with paid third-party costs, referral programmes, coupons, giveaways, and community or marketplace signups where fake accounts harm others. Ask for a permanent address with a clear message rather than a vague error.
When should you allow them?
Allow them, perhaps with limits, when the account itself is harmless: newsletters, documentation, downloads and read-only tools. Some privacy-minded people use disposable inboxes for exactly these. A common middle path is to let the account in but withhold free credits until the person adds a permanent address.
What about privacy email aliases?
Treat them separately. Forwarding services such as SimpleLogin, Firefox Relay and DuckDuckGo addresses deliver mail to a real inbox the person keeps, so the account is reachable and long-lived. Blocking them mainly turns away privacy-conscious customers. Allow aliases, and if rewards are a concern, limit those rather than the signup.
What is the risk of blocking too much?
False positives. A rule that blocks a real company's domain, a free provider or a whole domain ending turns away paying customers, usually without you noticing. Act on clear categories, treat unknown as unknown rather than blocking it, and give people a way to report a mistake.
A simple policy you can start with
Disposable: ask for another address, or allow without credits. Testing inboxes: block in production. Free email and aliases: allow. Parked domains and domains that cannot receive mail: ask the person to check the address. Unknown: allow and flag for review. You can model this policy with the free signup policy lab before you build it.
Source for provider behavior: Disban methodology. Product-policy guidance is Disban's interpretation.